Should I do Roof Repair or Replacement? Pros and Cons

Are you considering roof repair or replacement in Debary? Call PRS Roofing, FL, at (800) 750-9198.

Deciding to repair or replace a roof isn’t as simple as choosing the color. Repairing or replacing a roof is a major home improvement project requiring significant consideration to ensure you get good value for money.

Can a roof be repaired instead of replaced?

Yes, a roof can be repaired and not replaced. The best option is to have local roofers near you do a roof inspection and then add a roof coat to make the roof last longer.

Should I repair or replace a roof?

Request a roof inspection before deciding. Sometimes, you will save more money if you replace the whole roof than repairing it.

You don’t want to fill out damaged spots using new shingles only to discover that the problem is beyond a surface makeover. Similarly, you don’t want to splurge on a new roof and then find out that you could have avoided the heavy expense with some minor repairs.

Pros and Cons of Roof Repair vs Replacement

Here’s a breakdown of the pros and cons to help you decide between roof repair and replacement:

Roof Repair

Pros:

• Cost-effective: Repairs are cheaper than a complete replacement, especially for minor damage.
• Time-saving: Repairs are generally quicker, minimizing disruption to your home.
• Extends roof life: Addressing minor issues promptly can prevent further damage and extend your roof’s lifespan.
• DIY possibility: Depending on the size and complexity of the repair, some DIY repairs might be possible.

Cons:

• Temporary fix: Repairs might not be a long-term solution, especially for widespread damage.
• Matching issues: Matching existing shingles for repairs can be difficult, affecting aesthetics.
• Cost per square foot: While overall repairs are cheaper, the cost per square foot for repairs can be higher than replacement due to less bulk material pricing.
• Requires skilled professionals: Even for minor repairs, skilled roofers are recommended to ensure proper installation and avoid future leaks.

Roof Replacement

Pros:

• Long-term solution: A new roof provides peace of mind and protection for many years.
• Increased value: A new roof can boost your home’s resale value.
• Improved efficiency: Modern roofing materials can offer better insulation and energy efficiency.
• Curb appeal: A new roof enhances the overall look of your house.

Cons:

• Significant cost: Replacing a roof is a major investment.
• Disruption: The project can take longer and involve more mess and noise.
• Not always necessary: If the damage is minimal, a replacement might not be the best use of resources.

Making the Decision

The best option depends on the extent of the damage and your budget. Here’s a general guideline:

• Minor leaks or damage: Opt for repairs.
• Widespread damage, nearing lifespan, or considering selling: Replacement is likely the better choice.

Consulting a Professional

No matter which option you choose, consulting a qualified roofing contractor is crucial. They can assess the damage, recommend the best course of action, and provide accurate estimates for both repairs and replacements.

When to Repair or Repair My Roof?

You should consult a professional roof repair company like PRS Roofing in Debary for candid advice. To start, we’ll look at the main factors you must consider to make the right choice below.

The Roof’s Age

Most roofing materials are durable enough to protect against extreme weather and the elements. However, no roof has an infinite lifespan. You must look at the projected lifespan of your roof before making any decisions.

For example, asphalt shingles will last around 20 years, while metal and clay roofing tiles can last more than 50 years. Ideally, your roof will last as long as possible before you need to replace it. Replacing a roof near the end of its lifecycle or beyond is always the better choice.

Fast roof installation by PRS Roofing will make the replacement process straightforward. We’ll help you choose the best roofing option for your home.

The Roof Condition

The next factor to consider when looking to repair or replace a roof is the roof condition and the extent of the damage. Does the roof show extreme wear and tear, or are you looking at cosmetic damage?

The size of the affected area can help you decide if repair or replacement is better for you. For damage in isolated or limited spaces, you can trust a roofing company to repair it. However, replacing the entire roof is better if the damage affects more than 30% of the roof’s area.

Unfortunately, assessing the damage with a simple visual check is not always easy. Therefore, it’s best to work with experienced roofing contractors to uncover all hidden problems with a thorough roof inspection.

Your Timetable Concerning the Property

If you intend to live on the property for the next few decades, a replacement may be the more cost-effective choice. This is especially true if your length of stay will coincide with the end of the current roof’s lifespan.

However, roof repairs may work if you temporarily live on the property and intend to move soon. 

Contact PRS Roofing Today

You need to carefully weigh your options when you’re looking to repair or replace a roof. The project may cost thousands of dollars. So, you need to be sure you’re making the right choice.

At PRS roofing, we install new roofs and offer prompt roof repairs in Debary. Our professional team provides reliable services for both residential and commercial houses. Contact PRS roofing at (800) 750-9198 to book a consultation today.